Peer Review Process

All manuscripts submitted to DAB undergo a double-blind peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the process.

Stage 1 — Editorial Screening (14 days)

The Editor-in-Chief or a Section Editor screens each submission against four criteria:

1.        Scope: the manuscript falls within the Focus & Scope and contains substantial legal analysis.

2.        Engagement: the manuscript engages the relevant national, comparative, or international literature on agrarian law.

3.        Verifiable materials: statutes, regulations, judgments, customary rules, and field data are cited precisely and can be verified.

4.        Completeness: the manuscript is anonymised, is within the word limit, passes similarity screening (maximum 20%, excluding references), and includes all required declarations.

Manuscripts that fail these criteria are declined without external review (desk rejection), with a short statement of reasons.

Stage 2 — Reviewer Assignment

Each manuscript that passes screening is sent to at least two external reviewers, selected for subject-matter expertise rather than seniority. DAB applies a cross-jurisdictional rule: at least one reviewer must be based in a different country from the corresponding author, and, where possible, must work on a different legal system. Where a manuscript relies on fieldwork or customary law, the editor seeks at least one reviewer with socio-legal or anthropological expertise.

Stage 3 — Review Evaluation

Reviewers are asked to address five questions:

1.        Does the manuscript make an original contribution to agrarian law scholarship?

2.        Is the argument legible to readers outside the author’s jurisdiction, and does it engage the relevant comparative literature?

3.        Are statutes, judgments, customary rules, translations, and empirical data accurately presented?

4.        Is the argument sound in structure and evidence, and does it address contrary authority?

5.        Does the manuscript explain how law affects the balance among the State, the People, the Market, the Ecology, and Future Generations?

Stage 4 — Editorial Decision

The handling editor issues one of five decisions: accept, minor revisions, major revisions, reject and resubmit, or reject. Where reviewers materially disagree, a third review is obtained. Revised manuscripts are accompanied by a point-by-point response letter and may be returned to the original reviewers. Final acceptance is decided by the Editor-in-Chief.

Published Timelines

Stage

Target

Maximum

Acknowledgment of submission

3 days

7 days

Screening decision

14 days

21 days

First decision after external review

10 weeks

14 weeks

Decision on revised manuscript

4 weeks

6 weeks

Publication after acceptance

8 weeks

12 weeks

Submissions by editors or editorial board members are handled by another editor with no conflict of interest and follow the same procedure. Authors may appeal a decision once, in writing to the Editor-in-Chief, with reasons.